An actual real review of Themba's Head, from all the way across the big pond. Historic, and damn welcome, even if it's not altogether won-over.
David’s Rapier
Foreword by Denis. David Thomas, PhD (Sydney), was an SA journo, one-time parliamentary candidate (Progs – ancient days), and political science teacher. He’s now in the army of brainy Seffricans helping to boost Austrylia’s national IQ. He is also far advanced writing up a true story that in my (sometimes allegedly fervid) imagination might just end up as a hit in the same mould as Breaker Morant.
Here follows David’s critique of Themba’s Head. He scores many excellent points, including several that advance my understanding of what I’m talking about. I believe I have real replies to him. I’m putting him up here solus in the meantime. I hope you might see things you’d like to reply to.